Best Car Accident Lawyers in Orlando, FL

Top-Rated Car Accident Lawyers Near Me – Orlando, Florida ()

• Morgan & Morgan – Mega Firm
• Dan Newlin – Mega Firm
• Michael T. Gibson, P.A., Auto Justice Attorney – Mid-Sized Firm
• Todd Miner Law – Mid-Sized Firm
• Martinez Manglardi – Mid-Sized Firm
• Bogin, Munns & Munns – Mid-Sized Firm

The best car accident lawyers in Orlando typically fall into three categories: mega firms, mid-sized local practices, and small boutique firms. Each has its strengths, and depending on your situation, one may be a better fit than another.

Important: As attorneys, we’re guided by the Florida Bar Rules of Professional Conduct—which prohibit us from comparing ourselves to other lawyers or claiming we’re “better” than someone else. But what we can do is help you understand how the personal injury market in Central Florida works—and how to find a firm that aligns with your needs.

Why This Matters

If you’ve been injured in a crash, choosing the right lawyer can feel overwhelming. A quick search will likely take you to directories like Avvo, SuperLawyers, or Expertise.com—websites that claim to identify the “best” car accident lawyers in Orlando.

What many people don’t realize is that these platforms often rank attorneys based on who pays to appear. They’re not run by lawyers, and they’ve never helped a family navigate a serious injury claim or walked into a courtroom to fight for a client. Their rankings are built on marketing, not real legal experience. These don’t always reflect who will serve you best.

Hi, my name is Michael T. Gibson. I’m an Orlando car accident lawyer and an attorney based here in Orlando, and for nearly twenty years, my focus has been on helping people who’ve been injured in car accidents. I created this guide not to compete with those directories—but because I believe people deserve more than a paid list. You deserve a clear, honest explanation of your options, based on firsthand knowledge of what it actually takes to represent a car accident victim well.

Of course, I hope you’ll consider reaching out to my firm if you’re looking for help with a car accident claim. But more than anything, I want you to feel confident in whatever choice you make.

That’s why I put this guide together—to offer a clearer, more personal lens on your options. We’ve helped thousands of injured car accident victims here in Orlando—you can read some of their stories in our client testimonials and case results. Whether or not you choose to work with us, I want you to have the knowledge you need to make the right decision for you.

The Three Main Types of Car Accident Law Firms in Orlando

Here’s a quick comparison to help you visualize how these firm types differ:

When people search for the best car accident lawyer in Orlando, they’re usually not just looking for a name—they’re looking for someone who fits their needs and circumstances. That’s why I put together this breakdown. The table above offers a side-by-side view of the kinds of firms you’ll find here in Central Florida. It’s not about who claims to be “better”—it’s about understanding the differences so you can choose the team that aligns with what matters most to you: personal attention, deep resources, or something in between.

Let’s take a closer look at each type of firm so you can see how those differences show up in real cases. Whether your priority is hands-on communication, courtroom strength, or having a lawyer who truly knows the local landscape, my goal is to help you get clear on what’s out there—and what might be right for you.

1. Mega Firms

These are the firms you’ve likely seen on billboards or TV. They include:

• Morgan & Morgan – Listing on Google
  • Founder: John B. Morgan, Esq.
• Dan Newlin – Listing on Google
  • Founder: Daniel J. Newlin, Esq.

These firms have dozens (sometimes hundreds) of attorneys and thousands of active cases. Their size gives them deep financial strength and broad reach. In fact, we often work alongside them in multi-vehicle accidents where several firms are representing different victims.

What they do well:

• Massive advertising budgets bring in high volumes of cases
• Often have strong litigation resources
• Name recognition in the courtroom

Potential tradeoffs:

• High caseloads may limit personalized communication
• Clients sometimes feel like “just a number”
• Can be hard to reach your actual attorney

2. Mid-Sized Local Firms

These firms often have 5–20 attorneys and serve specific communities across Central Florida. Examples include:

• Michael T. Gibson, P.A. – Auto Justice Attorney – Listing on Google
  • Lead Attorney: Michael T. Gibson, Esq.
• Todd Miner Law – Listing on Google
  • Founder / Managing Attorney: Todd Miner, Esq.
• Martinez Manglardi – Listing on Google
  • Founding Attorney: Julio C. Martinez, Jr., Esq. 
  • Founding Attorney: Michael Manglardi, Esq.
• Bogin, Munns & Munns – Listing on Google
  • President: Spencer R. Munns, Esq.

These firms typically have strong ties to Central Florida and focus heavily on client relationships. Their size allows for more attorney-client contact than larger firms, while still maintaining the staff and resources needed to manage complex cases. Some—like Martinez Manglardi—focus on serving specific communities, while others, like our own, aim to provide a balance between trial readiness and hands-on service.

What these firms do well:

• More manageable caseloads than mega firms
• Closer attorney-client communication
• Strong local reputations

Potential tradeoffs:

• Fewer attorneys may limit case flexibility
• Not all firms take cases to trial

3. Boutique & Solo Practices

These smaller offices may consist of just one or two attorneys. While they often provide very close personal attention, they may lack the financial resources to battle large insurance carriers without co-counsel support.

What they do well:

• Very low client-to-attorney ratio
• Often accessible by phone or email directly
• Strong community roots

Potential tradeoffs:

• Limited bandwidth in complex litigation
• May need to partner with larger firms for trial support
• Less advertising = harder to verify online reputation

Our Approach: A Hybrid Model

At our firm, we’ve always believed the best client experience comes from blending the strengths of both large and small firms. We aim to provide:

• The personalized care of a boutique firm
• The resources and trial ability of a larger practice

There aren’t many firms trying to bridge that gap—but we are. We believe this hybrid approach gives clients the best shot at both a strong legal outcome and a smooth, human-centered experience.

Proven Results for Our Clients

Our team has recovered significant verdicts and settlements in serious injury cases. A few examples include:

• $1,970,002 — Wrongful Death, Trucking Accident
• $600,000 — Wrongful Death, Trucking Accident
• $1,475,000 — Wrongful Death, Trucking Accident
• $2,250,000 — Wrongful Death and Personal Injuries, Trucking Accident

See more case results

A Note on Ethics and Comparison

Some firms make sweeping claims about being “the best.” We don’t. The Florida Bar has strict rules that prohibit attorneys from comparing themselves to others, and for good reason. You deserve facts—not puffery.

That’s why this page isn’t a list of who we think is better than whom. It’s a breakdown of what types of firms exist and what you might expect when working with each. The decision, ultimately, is yours.

We Invite You to Reach Out

If you’ve been injured in a car accident in Orlando, you have real choices—and those choices matter.

Take time to evaluate your options. Ask about trial experience, communication style, and how involved your attorney will be in your case. And if you’d like to hear how our firm might help, we’re here. No pressure. Just a conversation.

Contact the Auto Justice Attorney

Orlando Car Accident Lawyer FAQ

How do I choose the best car accident lawyer near me in Orlando?

Look for experience with car crash litigation, trial readiness, recent case results, and clear communication. Verify Florida Bar status and read client reviews. Meet the team and ask who will handle your case day-to-day.

Do I pay a car accident lawyer upfront?

Most Orlando car accident lawyers work on a contingency fee. You pay nothing upfront; the fee is a percentage of the recovery, agreed to in writing.

How long do I have to file a claim in Florida?

Florida’s statute of limitations for most negligence claims is generally two years. Specific facts can change deadlines—ask an attorney about your date.

Will a big “mega firm” get me a better result?

Size cuts both ways. Mega firms bring resources; mid-sized and boutique firms often offer closer communication. Match the firm’s strengths to your needs.

The Author

Michael T. Gibson, Esq.

Michael T. Gibson is lead attorney and president of Michael T. Gibson, P.A., a law firm recognized throughout Orlando for experienced car accident lawyers who fight for the injured.

Raised in Clearwater and based in Orlando, Michael has tried over a dozen jury trials to verdict and has helped recover millions for injury victims across Central Florida. He frequently lectures on personal injury law and Florida auto insurance.